A Systematic Review of the Impact of Energy Insecurity on Mental Health During the COVID-19 Pandemic

Energy has long been a fundamental need for human survival, but its importance extends far beyond basic sustenance. In the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic, energy insecurity has emerged as a significant public health concern, particularly affecting the mental well-being of millions. This article delves into the systematic review of the impact of energy insecurity on mental health during the pandemic, highlighting the stark reality faced by many households.

Energy as a Social and Public Health Concern

Energy is an increasingly important social and public health concern. It is essential for good health and a prerequisite for basic needs in the household. The inability to meet these basic energy needs can lead to a cascade of negative effects on both physical and mental health, exacerbating existing health disparities.

The Crisis Point: Energy Insecurity

Energy insecurity refers to the inability of a household to meet its basic energy needs due to financial hardship. This can manifest in various ways, including difficulty paying energy bills, receiving shut-off notices, or even experiencing disconnections. The COVID-19 pandemic has significantly amplified this issue, as stay-at-home orders and economic disruptions have placed a substantial strain on household finances.

Prevalence and Disparities

The first year of the pandemic saw a staggering prevalence of energy insecurity among low-income households. Studies have shown that approximately 24% of all low-income households struggled to pay their bills, with 8% being completely disconnected from their service providers at least once. These numbers are particularly concerning given that many states implemented emergency disconnection moratoria to mitigate the issue, yet disconnections still occurred.

Who Is Most Affected?

Disparities in energy insecurity are stark. Households of color, those with young children, individuals relying on electronic medical devices, and those living in deficient housing conditions are disproportionately affected. These vulnerabilities are further compounded by structural racism, poor housing conditions, and limited financial aid for improving energy infrastructure.

The Mental Health Toll

Energy insecurity has a profound impact on mental health. The stress and anxiety associated with not knowing whether one's home will remain warm or lit can be overwhelming. This chronic stress can lead to a range of adverse mental health effects, including anxiety, depression, frustration, and even suicidal tendencies.

Home Confined: The Psychological Impact

The pandemic-induced lockdowns, which moved energy consumption from workplaces to residential homes, have exacerbated energy insecurity. Staying indoors, while necessary for safety, has increased the reliance on energy for heating, cooling, and lighting. This shift has placed a strain on household budgets, further intensifying the mental health burden.

Coping Strategies: Risky Trade-Offs

Households struggling with energy insecurity often resort to risky coping strategies to manage their bills. These strategies include reducing other essential expenses like housing, food, and medical care, or using financial and behavioral tactics such as taking on debt or relying on government assistance programs. These actions can lead to a vicious cycle of financial hardship and mental distress.

The Syndemic Effect

Energy insecurity and the COVID-19 pandemic interact in a synergistic way, amplifying each other's negative effects. The inability to maintain proper hygiene and sanitation, combined with the psychological strain of uncertainty, increases the risk of spreading COVID-19. This syndemic effect disproportionately affects vulnerable populations, exacerbating health inequities and mortality rates.

Policy and Programmatic Solutions

Addressing energy insecurity requires a multifaceted approach that involves both short-term solutions and long-term policy changes. Emergency disconnection moratoria, while helpful, are temporary measures. Permanent solutions involve investing in renewable energy sources, improving energy efficiency in housing, and enhancing financial assistance programs for low-income households.

State-Level Initiatives

State-level initiatives can play a crucial role in addressing energy insecurity. For example, some states have implemented programs to provide financial assistance to households struggling with energy bills. These programs, coupled with efforts to improve energy infrastructure and promote renewable energy, can significantly reduce energy insecurity.

Conclusion

The impact of energy insecurity on mental health during the COVID-19 pandemic is a crisis that cannot be ignored. It is essential to acknowledge the systemic disparities and implement comprehensive policies to address these issues. By doing so, we can mitigate the adverse effects on mental health and ensure that all households have access to basic energy needs, thereby promoting overall well-being.

Recommendations for Action

1. Invest in Renewable Energy: Transitioning to renewable energy sources can reduce reliance on expensive fossil fuels and provide more sustainable options for households.
2. Enhance Financial Assistance: Expanding financial assistance programs to help households pay their energy bills can alleviate immediate stress.
3. Improve Energy Efficiency: Investing in energy-efficient solutions for housing can reduce the financial burden on households.
4. Address Systemic Disparities: Implementing policies that address systemic disparities, such as those related to race and housing quality, can ensure equal access to energy resources.

By taking these steps, we can begin to address the hidden crisis of energy insecurity and its profound impact on mental health during the pandemic. It is our collective responsibility to ensure that no household is left in the dark, both literally and figuratively.

---

References

• The persistence of household energy insecurity during the COVID-19 pandemic.
  • IOPscience: https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/ac90d7/ampdf
• Energy Insecurity Is Underappreciated Social and Environmental Determinant of Health.
  • Public Health Columbia: https://www.publichealth.columbia.edu/news/energy-insecurity-underappreciated-social-environmental-determinant-health
• Household Energy Insecurity and COVID-19 Have Independent and Synergistic Effects.
  • NCBI: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7859644/
• Energy Insecurity During the Time of COVID.
  • Kleinman Energy: https://kleinmanenergy.upenn.edu/research/publications/energy-insecurity-during-the-time-of-covid/