Patients worry as Duke Health, UnitedHealthcare contract set to expire

Duke Health and UnitedHealthcare Face Deadline as Contract Negotiations Reach Critical Point

---

Introduction

In a situation that could significantly impact the health care of nearly 170,000 patients, Duke University Health System and UnitedHealthcare are embroiled in a contract dispute that has reached a critical juncture. The current agreement between the two parties is set to expire on November 1, 2024, and if no new deal is reached, patients covered by UnitedHealthcare could face higher out-of-pocket costs or the need to find a new healthcare provider.

The Stakes

The potential outcome of this contract dispute is more than just a battle over dollars and cents; it directly affects the well-being of thousands of patients. If the negotiations fail, Duke Health patients with UnitedHealthcare insurance would be considered out-of-network, meaning they would have to pay more for medical services or seek alternative care providers.

Background of the Dispute

Duke Health and UnitedHealthcare have been negotiating since April 2024, with no immediate resolution in sight. The health system has been clear about its concerns, stating that UnitedHealthcare's reimbursements have not kept up with inflation, making it challenging to provide quality care while maintaining financial stability.

Economic Concerns

Duke Health has emphasized that it must ensure fair reimbursement rates from all insurance companies, including UnitedHealthcare. The health system has pointed out that it is reimbursed by UnitedHealthcare at rates below the 25th percentile of its peer group in North Carolina, which is unacceptable given the rising costs of healthcare.

UnitedHealthcare's Perspective

UnitedHealthcare has countered by saying that it is committed to reaching an agreement that provides continued access to Duke Health while ensuring affordability for North Carolina families and employers. The insurance company has delivered multiple proposals, including one on October 1, 2024, which included meaningful rate increases to ensure that Duke Health is reimbursed similarly to peer health systems.

Previous Similar Disputes

This is not the first time a health system in the Triangle has found itself at odds with UnitedHealthcare. Last year, UNC Health faced a similar situation but managed to reach an agreement just four days before its contract expired. In 2022, WakeMed saw thousands of UnitedHealthcare patients go out of network for months before signing a new contract.

Impact on Patients

For patients like Gwendolyn Hairston, who have serious eye issues and rely on UnitedHealthcare, the uncertainty is particularly worrisome. "As someone with a serious eye issue, I'm very concerned about what will happen if the contract isn't renewed," Hairston said. "I need to make sure I have coverage in place to continue receiving the care I need."

Contingency Plans

Duke Health is actively working with brokers, employers, and patients to prepare for potential disruptions. The health system has emphasized its commitment to its patients, stating that it will continue to make great strides in providing cutting-edge care despite the challenges. However, the financial strain posed by UnitedHealthcare's offer is significant, and Duke Health cannot risk its financial well-being without a fair agreement.

What's Next?

The negotiations between Duke Health and UnitedHealthcare are ongoing, with both parties committed to finding a solution. However, time is running out. If no agreement is reached by November 1, 2024, patients will face significant changes in their healthcare coverage.

Key Points to Consider

• Impact on Patients: Nearly 170,000 patients could be affected, with many facing higher out-of-pocket costs or needing to find new healthcare providers.
• Economic Concerns: Duke Health is seeking fair reimbursement rates to cover the rising costs of healthcare.
• UnitedHealthcare's Response: The insurance company has delivered multiple proposals, including meaningful rate increases, but has not moved significantly on Duke Health's demands.
• Previous Disputes: Other health systems in the Triangle have faced similar issues with UnitedHealthcare in the past.
• Contingency Plans: Duke Health is preparing for potential disruptions by working with brokers, employers, and patients.

Conclusion

The contract dispute between Duke Health and UnitedHealthcare is a critical issue that affects not just the financial stability of the health system but also the well-being of thousands of patients. While both parties are committed to finding a solution, the clock is ticking. As the deadline approaches, patients are left waiting anxiously for news that could significantly impact their healthcare.

References

• Duke Health Contract Dispute Could Cause Major Coverage Risks to Patients. Retrieved from https://ncmedsoc.org/duke-health-contract-dispute-could-cause-major-coverage-risks-to-patients/.
• Duke Health warns patients of coverage risks amid contract dispute. Retrieved from https://www.axios.com/local/raleigh/2024/08/20/duke-health-contract-unitedhealthcare-expire-patients-out-of-network.
• Duke University Health System Addresses UHC Negotiations. Retrieved from https://corporate.dukehealth.org/news/duke-university-health-system-addresses-uhc-negotiations.
• Latest News - Duke Health. Retrieved from https://www.dukehealth.org/health-insurance/duke-health-access-united/news.
• Network Negotiations with Duke Health - UnitedHealthcare. Retrieved from https://www.uhc.com/duke.