Sleep Tracking Is Bad for My Mental Health, Actually
- Sleep tracking devices, while useful for monitoring sleep patterns, can increase anxiety by causing obsessive monitoring and stressing users about not meeting sleep goals, which can be particularly troubling for parents and lead to negative mental health outcomes.
- These devices often provide a false sense of security and inaccurate data, potentially misleading users about their real sleep quality, which can lead to frustration and exacerbate symptoms of sleep disturbances and mental health issues.
- While smartphones and wearables offer convenient sleep monitoring tools, their accuracy and effectiveness in improving mental health remain questionable, suggesting the need for cautious use of sleep tracking technology to avoid additional stress.
Join Our Newsletter
Get the latest news, updates, and exclusive content delivered straight to your inbox.
The Dark Side of Sleep Monitoring
Sleep tracking has become a staple in our modern lives. Devices and apps promise to help us monitor our sleep patterns, giving us valuable insights into our rest. However, a growing number of people are discovering that this technology can have a detrimental effect on their mental health. In this article, we delve into the surprising ways in which sleep tracking can stress us out and explore the potential harm it can cause.
The Stress of Knowing: How Sleep Trackers Can Create Anxiety
Sleep trackers are designed to provide us with detailed information about our sleep quality. They track our movements, heart rate, and breathing, often breaking down our slumber into different stages. While this data can be useful for understanding our sleep patterns, it can also create a sense of anxiety. Many people find themselves obsessed with their tracker's reports, constantly checking to see if they've met their daily sleep goals.
For parents, this obsession can be particularly stressful. The constant reminders of how much sleep they're not getting can lead to feelings of guilt and inadequacy. As one parent noted, "Sleep tracking has gotten so good at telling me I'm a rest-deprived parent that it now stresses me out." This sentiment is echoed by many, who feel that the relentless focus on sleep metrics can be overwhelming and anxiety-inducing.
The False Sense of Security
One of the primary issues with sleep trackers is that they can provide a false sense of security. If a tracker indicates that you've had a good night's sleep, you might feel relieved, only to discover later that you actually woke up multiple times during the night. This discrepancy can lead to frustration and worry, as you question your tracker's accuracy.
As Dr. Kelly Baron, a sleep researcher at the University of Utah School of Medicine, explains, "For some people, the tracking can get a little overboard. Focusing too much on your numbers can get in the way of your slumber. You may worry about scoring a solid 8 hours of sleep, so you go to bed extra early. But if you turn in when you're not tired, you're more likely to toss and turn throughout the night." This phenomenon is not unique to parents; anyone who relies heavily on sleep tracking can fall prey to this trap.
The Impact on Mental Health
Sleep disturbances are a common symptom of many mental health disorders, including anxiety and depression. However, sleep tracking can exacerbate these issues by creating an unhealthy obsession. Constantly monitoring your sleep can lead to a vicious cycle:
- Anxiety: The more you focus on your sleep, the more anxious you become about not meeting your targets.
- Insomnia: This anxiety can lead to difficulty falling asleep or staying asleep, further worsening insomnia.
- Depression: The stress and guilt associated with poor sleep can contribute to feelings of depression.
This bidirectional relationship between sleep and mental health is highlighted by the Sleep Foundation, which notes that "sleep issues can worsen mental health conditions, and mental health problems can lead to poor sleep." By introducing yet another stressor into this delicate balance, sleep trackers can inadvertently worsen mental health outcomes.
The Accuracy Conundrum
Another critical issue with sleep trackers is their accuracy. While they offer valuable insights into our sleep patterns, they are not always reliable. For instance, a tracker may report that you're asleep when you're actually quietly watching TV in bed. This can lead to misleading results, causing you to feel more anxious about your sleep quality than necessary.
Dr. Jerald Simmons, the founding director of Comprehensive Sleep Medicine Associates in Houston, points out that "these devices analyze your behavior, but they can't tell if you're really asleep." This lack of accuracy can be particularly problematic when relying on trackers for diagnosis or treatment planning.
The Case of Obstructive Sleep Apnea
Obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) is another sleep disorder that can be influenced by the use of sleep trackers. OSA is characterized by pauses in breathing during sleep, leading to fragmented and disturbed rest. This condition is more common among individuals with psychiatric conditions and can exacerbate mental distress.
For those with OSA, the stress of tracking sleep can be compounded by the constant awareness of breathing difficulties. The anxiety of not knowing if you’ll experience an apneic episode can disrupt sleep even further, creating a cycle of poor sleep and heightened anxiety.
Smartphones and Wearables: A Double-Edged Sword
In recent years, smartphones and wearables have become increasingly popular tools for monitoring sleep. These devices offer convenient and accessible ways to track our rest patterns. However, as highlighted by researchers in the field of psychiatric disorders, their effectiveness in improving sleep and mental health outcomes is still limited.
For instance, a study published in the National Center for Biotechnology Information found that smartphones can be used to assess and monitor sleep, but there is a need for more research on their long-term adherence and personalized systems to predict risk and relapse. Moreover, the accuracy of self-reported sleep symptoms is often questionable due to cognitive impairment associated with psychiatric disorders.
Conclusion
Sleep tracking can be a valuable tool in understanding our sleep patterns, but it also carries significant risks for mental health. The constant monitoring can create anxiety, provide false senses of security, and exacerbate existing sleep disturbances. Furthermore, the accuracy of these devices is often questionable, which can lead to further stress and frustration.
It's essential to approach sleep tracking with caution and awareness. While technology can be a powerful ally in managing our health, it should not become an additional source of stress. By recognizing the potential pitfalls of sleep tracking and maintaining a balanced perspective on our sleep metrics, we can harness the benefits of this technology without compromising our mental well-being.
References:
